Old realities that need to change for a church to grow | Church Size with Chad Brooks


This past week, I read Lovett Weems’ new book, An Aura of Hope. Weems has been a voice in United Methodist Church Renewal for decades and established the Lewis Center for Church Leadership in 2003. His voice has always been welcome.

This isn’t a book review, but I did take plenty of great notes on the book. What I want to share with you today is a specific focus from An Aura of Hope that I find in my work with local churches. Difficult conversations are necessary for churches to adapt and reach new people.

These four points outline the new reality. They help churches understand that old tactics and expectations won't bring them into a new day.

New members will come from new residents.
In the past, churches grew by people moving into the neighborhood.
They were already like them, and most likely already had an affiliation with the denomination. In short - they were already disciples and knew what to do.

New members will come from young couples returning to church when they have children.
I’ve written plenty on generational dynamics, so I won’t go into it here.

In short - the younger someone is, the more likely it is they aren’t part of a Christian tradition. Couple this with the fact people are getting married and having children later…this assumption no longer works.

New members will be younger than current members.
Think back to the last point. Assuming young people isn’t a given. In fact, especially when the church is primarily made up of people over the age of 60, a focus on people in their 20’s and 30’s might be difficult, or at least won’t look like the current congregation. I instead suggest these churches begin concentrating on people one generation cohort lower than themselves. Is your church over 65? Focus on Gen X. These are people between the ages of 46 and 61.

New members will look like us and share our values.
One unique point of research I am doing with local churches currently is mapping where the existing members live. We are discovering that many church members live OUTSIDE the historic mission field of the church.

As Tim Keller puts it, “Soon the congregation doesn’t look like the neighborhood and can’t reach its own geographic community.”

Local churches have been thinking of their mission relationally and not geographically. This makes it much harder to experience revitalization. The frustration many churches experience is because they are banking on relational mission. This doesn't discount the power of relationships, but it must focus on the geographic mission field.

I’ll leave you with a quote from Weems from An Aura of Hope.

Organizations in decline desperately need leadership, but they tend to reward good managers who keep the forms of the past operating to give a false sense that everything is like it used to be. -Lovett Weems

The biggest indicator I have discovered of a congregation's ability to experience revitalization isn’t money, but the ability to have difficult conversations that lead to a transformative future. Thinking through these four points, Lovett Weems gives us would be a wise conversation.

Chad

Hey. I'm Chad Brooks.

I steward Productive Pastor, a podcast and community of ministry leaders focused on how productivity and strategic ministry in the average church. I write about practical approaches to ministry productivity. I also write emails about church stability/development and my own theological musics in our current social moment.

Read more from Hey. I'm Chad Brooks.

For the past year, I’ve been on a personal tear about the church and social media. For the gist of it, here’s a video about one of the biggest mistakes I see churches make. The TLDR is that many pastors and other leaders in normal-size churches don’t understand how the algorithm drives Facebook, to really get traction, you have to pay to play, and the realization that many churches' posting strategies are actually HURTING their ability to reach people on Social Media. What’s the biggest...

A decade ago, when I was church planting, I was in a season where I wasn’t “at” a local on Sunday mornings. I spent some of that time preaching for colleagues when they needed a Sunday off. I also led worship at another United Methodist Church frequently. But on the Sundays when I didn’t have some assignment at a local church, I decided to skip church. I think you need to do it every now and then as well. Does this sound a bit off? Well, I realized this past week how the idea is actually...

Let’s wrap up these conversations on “calling on the name of the Lord” as a primary spiritual act. I’ve got a few articles* you can read if you want to catch up, but let’s get right into it. You might know I’ve got a really intense system of Bible notes and list-making. One of my commenters on YouTube remarked last year, it seems like what you might find in the Thompson Chain Reference. I’ll call that a compliment! This feeds into today. It isn’t about a specific mention of “calling on the...